Song Yan, Tang Yu, Ding Guosheng, Chen Yanping

Keywords： Plan Document Evaluation; Internal Validity; External Validity; Assessment Methods

Abstract：

The article takes a case study of comprehensive planning document evaluation in the United States to reveal the content and methods of plan document evaluation. It is found that the content of plan document evaluation mainly focuses on the internal validity and external validity of plan formulation and on the methodology, planning document evaluation protocols can be an important tool for conducting a plan document evaluation and “multiparty jointed evaluation” can be an effective work mechanism to guarantee an objective and accurate evaluation result. It points out that there are still lots of problems in both internal validity and external validity of planning formulation in China. It also suggests that we should promote the plan document evaluation to make it as an important tool for planning approval and self-examination of planners in their daily work.

Funds：

• [1] Berke D Godschalk. Searching for the Good Plan: A Meta-Analysis of Plan

  Quality Studies[J]. Journal of Planning Literature, 2009, 23(3): 227-240.

  [2] 宋彦, 陈燕萍. 城市规划评估指引[M]. 北京: 中国建筑工业出版社, 2012.

  [3] 宋彦, 江志勇, 杨晓春, 陈燕萍. 北美城市规划评估实践经验及启示[J].

  规划师, 2010, 26(3): 5-9.

  [4] Brody Samuel D. Are We Learning to Make Better Plans?: A Longitudinal

  Analysis of Plan Quality Associated with Natural Hazards[J]. Journal of

  Planning Education and Research, 2003, 23(2): 191-201.

  [5] Berke Philip R. Enhancing Plan Quality: Evaluating the Role of

  State Planning Mandates for Natural Hazard Mitigation[J]. Journal of

  Environmental Planning and Management, 1996, 39(1): 79-96.

  [6] Conroy Berke. What Makes a Good Sustainable Development Plan?:

  An Analysis of Factors that Influence Principles of Sustainable

  Development[J]. Environment and Planning A, 2004, 36(8): 1381-1396.

  [7] 张昊哲, 宋彦, 陈燕萍, 金广君. 城市总体规划的内在有效性评估探讨:

  兼谈美国城市总体规划的成果表达[J]. 规划师, 2010, 26(6): 59-64.

  [8] The City of New York. New York Master Plam 2008-2030[Z]. 2007.

  [9] 宋彦, 彭科. 城市总体规划促进低碳城市实现途径探讨: 以美国纽约市

  为例[J]. 规划师, 2011, 27(4): 94-99.

  [10] Song Y, Knaap G. Measuring Urban Form: Is Portland Winning the War

  on Sprawl?[J]. Journal of the American Planning Association, 2004, 70(2):

  210-225.

  [11] Philip R Berke, Maria Manta Conroy. Are We Planning for Sustainable

  Development?: An Evaluation of 30 Comprehensive Plans[J]. APA Journal,

  2000, 66(1): 21-33.

  [12] 李智慧, 宋彦, 陈燕萍. 城市规划的外在有效性评估探讨: 以深圳市城

  市规划为例[J]. 规划师, 2010, 26(3): 25-30.