Modelling Approaches for Retrofitting Energy Systems in Cities: Current Practice and Future Challenges in Newcastle upon Tyne

Carlos Calderon, Macarena Rodriguez

Keywords: Urban Regeneration; Urban Energy Consumption; Energy Consumption Model; Rebound Effect; Demand Side Management


The paper reviews the UK carbon agenda and current local practices and challenges in urban energy modelling as to highlight the lack of models and quantitative understanding of the interplay between technical and social systems. The paper also reviews existing modelling household practices and energy demand to contextualize the emphasis of our study( i.e. take back effect and demand side management) and the rationale behind our selected approach: activity base model. The model is used to model and quantify two salient aspects of the interaction between retrofitted technical systems and household practices:( 1) rebound effect; and( 2) demand side management. By applying the model,the paper presents a case study using 200 social households in Newcastle upon Tyne. Finally,we propose a theoretical model and its detailed implementation. The modeling results have important theoretical and practical implications for the development of planning decision support system for urban regeneration. 


Brief Info of Author(s):

  • [1] Alcott B, Giampietro M, Mayumi K, Polimeni J M. The Jevons Paradox and the Myth of Resource Efficiency Improvements[M]. London: Earthscan, 2012. 

    [2] Aruna S. Activity-based Modelling for Urban Energy System [M] // Keirstead J, Shah N, eds. Urban Energy Systems: An Integrated Approach. London: Routledge, 2013. 

    [3] Axelrod R M. The Complexity of Cooperation: Agent-based Models of Competition and Collaboration[M]. Princeton: Princeton University Press, 1997. 

    [4] Axhausen K W. Can we ever obtain the data we would like to have[M] // G?rling T, Laitila T, Westin K. Theoretical Foundations of Travel Choice Modeling. Amsterdam: Elsevier Science BV, 1998: 305-323. 

    [5] Bonabeau E. Agent-based Modeling: Methods and Techniques for Simulating Human Systems[J]. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America, 2002, 99 (3): 7280-7287. 

    [6] Calderon C, Keirstead J. Modelling Frameworks for Delivering Low-carbon Cities: Advocating a Normalized Practice[J]. Building Research & Information, 2012, 40 (4): 504-517. 

    [7] Chappells H, Shove E. Debating the Future of Comfort: Environmental Sustainability, Energy Consumption and the Indoor Environment[J] Building Research & Information, 2005, 33 (1): 32-40. 

    [8] Davoudi S, Brooks E. Environmental Justice and the City: Full Report[R]. Newcastle: Newcastle University, Global Urban Research Unit, 2012. 

    [9] Druckman A, Jackson T. Household Energy Consumption in the UK: A Highly Geographically and Socio-Economically Disaggregated Model[J]. Energy Policy, 2008, 36 (8): 3177-3192. 

    [10] Gellings C W, Barron W, Betley F M, England W A, Preiss L L, Jones D E. Integrating Demand-side Management into Utility Planning[J]. Power Systems, IEEE Transactions on, 1986, 1 (3): 81-87. 

    [11] Greening L, Greene D L, Difiglio C. Energy Efficiency and Consumption - The Rebound Effect - A Survey[J]. Energy Policy, 2000, 28 (6): 389-401. 

    [12] Guy S, Marvin S, Moss T. Urban Infrastructure in Transition: Networks, Buildings and Plans[M]. London: Earthscan, 2001. 

    [13] IEA. Implementing Agreement on Demand-side Management Technologies and Programmes, 2011 Annual Report[EB/OL]. Paris: International Energy Agency, 2012 [2013-09-11]. File%20Library/Annual%20Reports/REV.Annual%20report_2011C_lag. pdf . 

    [14] Jager W. Modelling Consumer Behaviour[R]. Groningen: University of Groningen, Centre for Environmental and Traffic Psychology, 2000. 

    [15] Jennings, M. Building Energy Service Demands: The Potential of Retrofits[M] // Keirstead J, Shah N, eds. Urban Energy Systems: An Integrated Approach. London: Routledge, 2013. 

    [16] Kane T, Firth S K, Allinson D, Irvine K, Lomas K J. Understanding Occupant Heating Practices In UK Dwellings[C] // Proceedings of World Renewable Energy Congress 2011. Link?ping, Sweden, 2011. 

    [17] Keirstead J, Calderon C. Capturing Spatial Effects, Technology Interactions, and Uncertainty in Urban Energy and Carbon Models: Retrofitting Newcastle as a Case-study[J]. Energy Policy, 2012 (46): 253- 267. 

    [18] Keirstead J, Shah N. Urban Energy Systems: An Integrated Approach[M]. London: Routledge, 2013. 

    [19] Keirstead J, Sivakumar A. Using Activity-based Modeling to Simulate Urban Resource Demands at High Spatial and Temporal Resolutions[J]. Journal of Industrial Ecology, 2012, 16 (6): 889-900. 

    [20] Martinez-Moyano I J, Zhao F, Simunich K L, Graziano D J, Conzelmann G. Modeling the Commercial Buildings Sector: An Agent-Based Approach, ASHRAE Annual Conference[C]. Montreal: ASHRAE Transactions, 2011. 

    [21] Maya Sopha B, Kl?ckner C A, Hertwich E G. Exploring policy Options for a Transition to Sustainable Heating System Diffusion Using an Agent-based Simulation[J]. Energy Policy, 2011, 39 (5): 2722-2729. 

    [22] Miller E J, Roorda M J. Prototype Model of Household Activity-travel Scheduling[J]. Transportation Research Record: Journal of the Transportation Research Board, 2003, 1831 (1): 114-121. 

    [23] Milne G, Boardman B. Making Cold Homes Warmer: The Effect of Energy Efficiency Improvements in Low-income Homes[J]. Energy Policy, 2000, 28 (6): 411-424. 

    [24] Newcastle City Council. Citywide Climate Change Strategy and Action Plan 2010-2020 (Draft)[EB/OL]. Newcastle City Council, 2010. http:// blicConsultationClimateChangeStrategyActionPlanJune2010.pdf. 

    [25] Palmer J, Sorda G, Madlener R. Modeling the Diffusion of Residential Photovoltaic Systems in Italy: An Agent-based Simulation[R]. Aachen: RWTH Aachen University, Institute for Future Energy Consumer Needs and Behavior, 2013. 

    [26] Pinjari A R, Bhat C R. Activity-based Travel Demand Analysis[M] // Palma A, Lindsey R, Quinet E, Vickerman R, eds. A Handbook of Transport Economics. Cheltenham: Edward Elgar, 2011: 213-248. 

    [27] Powells G, Bulkeley H, Judson E, Bell S. Smart Grids and the Flexibility of Everyday Life[C] // Proceedings: 12th Annual IAS-STS Conference: Critical Issues in Science and Technology Studies. Graz, Austria, 2013. 

    [28] Rhoads J. Low Carbon Retrofit Toolkit - A Roadmap to Success[EB/OL]. London: Better Buildings Partnership, 2010[2014-01-15]. http://www. toolkit.pdf. 

    [29] Samsatli N, Jennings M. Optimization and systems integration[M] // Keirstead J, Shah N, eds. Urban Energy Systems: An Integrated Approach. London: Routledge, 2013. 

    [30] Sanders C, Phillipson M. Review of Differences Between Measured and Theoretical Energy Savings for Insulation Measures[R]. Glasgow: Glasgow Caledonian University, 2006. 

    [31] Shackley S, Fleming P, Bulkeley H. Low Carbon Spaces Area-based 

    Carbon Emission Reduction: A Scoping Study[R]. London: Sustainable Development Commission, 2002. 

    [32] Shah N. Modelling Urban Energy System[M] // Keirstead J, Shah N, eds. Urban Energy Systems: An Integrated Approach. London: Routledge, 2013. 

    [33] Shorrock L D, Henderson J, Utley J I. Reducing Carbon Emissions from the UK Housing Stock[M]. Watford: BRE Press, 2005. 

    [34] Shove E. Comfort, Cleanliness and Convenience: The Social Organization of Normality[M]. Oxford: BERG Publishers, 2003. 

    [35] Shove E, Watson M, Hand M, Ingram J. The Design of Everyday Life[M]. Oxford: BERG Publishers, 2007. 

    [36] Sorrell S. The Rebound Effect: An Assessment of the Evidence for Economy-wide Energy Savings from Improved Energy Efficiency[R]. UK Energy Research Centre, 2007. 

    [37] Trochim W M K, Donnelly J P. The Research Methods Knowledge Base[M]. Cincinnati, OH: Atomic Dog/Cengage Learning, 2008. 

    [38] Vale B, Vale R. Domestic Energy Use, Lifestyles and POE: Past Lessons for Current Problems[J]. Building Research & Information, 2010, 38 (5): 578-588. 

    [39] Zhang T, Nuttall W J. An Agent Based Simulation of Smart Metering Technology Adoption[R]. University of Cambridge: Judge Institute of Management, 2007. 

TOP 10